x

History of Banana Republics

References
  • The Dark History of Bananas | TED-Ed | YouTube.com
  • The Banana Republics | Sam O'Neilla Academy | YouTube.com

Introduction

  • It started in early 1900s when agriculture was getting popular in Central and South America - with several plantations of bananas, sugar, etc.
  • Refrigerators arrived, so food could be stored for longer, and thus food trade could happen internationally
  • The biggest trade partner was the USA
  • There were three main companies in the area: United Fruit Co., Cuyamel Fruit Co., Vaccaro Bros.
  • They bought out smaller family owned plantations
  • They became their own competitions

Notes from TED-Ed

Some Early History

  • Bananas were first cultivated in south-east Asia thousands of years ago
  • They reached the Americas in the early 1500s
  • Enslaved Africans cultivated them in plots alongside sugar plantations.

1800s-1900s

  • In the 1800s captains from New Orleans and New England ventured to the Caribbean in search for coconuts and other goods
  • They liked the Gros Michel bananas from Afro-Caribbean farmers in Jamaica, Cuba and Honduras
  • They produced large bunches of thick skinned fruit
  • By the end of 1800s, bananas were a big hit in the US

Events of 1900s

  • As they became big business, US fruit companies wanted to grow there own bananas
  • In order to secure access to land, banana moguls lobbied and bribed government officials in Central America, and funded coups to ensure they had allies in power
  • By 1930, United Fruit dominated the region, and owned over 40% of Guatemala's arable land
  • They cleared rainforests in Costa Rica, Colombia, Guatemala, Honduras and Panama to build plantations, and railroads, ports and towns to house workers.

The state of banana farms due to lack of biodiversity

  • People migrated to banana zones to get high paying jobs
  • From Guatemala to Colombia, United Fruit grew exclusively Gros Michel bananas
  • These farms had low biological diversity, and was prone to epidemics
  • Because of the connected railroads, diseases were easy to spread from one farm to another
  • In 1910s, a fungus began to level Gros Michel plantations, by the same infrastructure that enabled quick profits - this was called the "Panama Disease"
  • Banana companies abandoned plantations in infected areas, and the workers were left jobless
  • The companies then fell extensive tracks of rainforests to establish new plantations
  • After running away from Panama Disease, United Fruits finally switched to Panama disease-resistant Cavendish bananas in the early 1960s.

The First Incident

  • 1910: Cuyamel used to function mostly in Honduras
  • The president of Honduras gave land grants to Vaccaro Bros. in exchange for helping them build roads
  • This put Cuyamel at a disadvantage, as their competitor got more of their potential lands.
  • The owner of Cuyamel, Samuel Zemurray, enraged by this funded a mercenary army and gave them to the exiled former Honduran president Manuel Bonilla, and together they overthrew the Honduran government
  • Bonilla took control and gave big concessions to Cuyamel and United Fruit as thanks
  • When USA had concerns about this, Zemurray bribed them by striking a deal with them

Notes from TED-Ed

  • Bonilla was backed by the future leader of the US organization formally known as United Fruit Co., and known throughout Latin America as El Pulpo, or "the octopus", signifying it's reach over the countries.
  • El Pulpo was a corporation trafficking in bananas

Taking Capitalist Control of Infrastructure

  • Since they were really funded by the government, their commerce did not benefit Honduras as a whole much
  • The national debt of Honduras got so bad that the government was not able to control it
  • So the three fruit countries claimed to help them, and decided to build the nation's entire infrastructure - roads, railways, shipping lines, telegraph lines, telephone lines, radio towers - and switched the whole country to using US dollars.
  • In effect, they had complete control over the infrastructure

How Other Countries Followed Suit and Freedom Plummeted

  • Other countries followed suit - Guatamela, El Salvador, Nicaragua, Costa Rica
  • Hence the Banana republics were born
  • Fruit companies get tax breaks and land grants, in exchange for which they built infrastructure
  • So basically the direct shareholders got high profits, while the rest of the population had to work in farms for terrible wages
  • So, capitalism works, by spreading the illusion that if you are smart, you can be as rich as you want by honest labour - with a little bit of dirty play - which is okay because everyone does that, and only fools are nice - and we all know nice guys finish last

USA's Anti-Communist State Terrorism

  • After a decade, Cuyamel was bought by United Fruit, but Zemurray became the owner of United later
  • Vacarro Bros. was renamed as Standard Fruit
  • After WW II, in 1944, Guatamela had a democratic revolution
  • The newly elected leader Juan Jose Arevalo was unhappy with the way the companies treated the people, so he implemented several reforms like minimum wage laws and universal suffrage
  • He tried to buy back land from the United Fruit company and give it to the poor
  • But while this helped the general population, more rights for people meant less profits for United Fruit
  • Then Guatamela got a new president, Jacobo Arbenz, who continued these reforms
  • He offered to pay prices based on tax records, where United Fruit had constantly under-reported the values
  • In 1953, United Fruit went to USA for help and they scared US president Eisenhower by mentioning how Jacobo is making them pay minimum wages, and how they are sharing their unused land to the poor, sharing resources, leading to collectivization, which is just communism
  • USA's CIA, citing fears of communism overthrew the democratically elected Arbenz government and Guatamela was ruled by a series of US-backed dictatorships from 1954-1966
  • This happened in many other places due to the fear of red (commies) and love for yellow (bananas)

How These Companies Still Exist

  • In the present day
  • Standard Fruit changed to Dole Food Company in 1991
  • In 1976, the CEO of United Fruit jumped out of their office window due to pressure, and the company was acquired by someone else who renamed it to Chiquita Brands International

Present Day Problems

  • The political power is no longer the same with Chiquita Bananas
  • However, they require frequent application of pesticides which create hazards for farm workers and the ecosystem
  • Although they are resistant to the Panama disease, Cavendish farms too lack biological diversity and hence may wind up with another disease
Left-click: follow link, Right-click: select node, Scroll: zoom
x